Five Advantages and Disadvantages to Online Banking

A few months back, I opened an account at HSBC Direct and moved nearly all my money over to this online bank. This was after quite a lot of deliberation on trying to balance the advantages I would receive from online banking compared to what I would be losing from local banking.

So what have I learned in six months of online banking?

  1. It is extremely difficult to survive without paper checks. Nearly all major online banks do not offer paper checks. They instead tout their online, free bill pay systems, which for the most part work very well. I have a few checks that go out each month automatically for utilities, loans, and rent. Yet I still find myself writing a paper check about once a month. For instance, this month I had to pay the DMV for registration on my new car, and I couldn’t possibly have mailed them a check through bill-pay instead. This Sunday I need a check for my new apartment deposit.

    I keep $300 in my local checking account for these situations, but often times the check is more than $300, which means I need to transfer funds from my online bank. The problem is that it takes a full four business days to complete this transaction. So if I ever need to write a check for more than $300 without four days notice, I am in a bit of trouble! The only solution I see is to keep more money in my local checking account, but that reduces the benefit I get from interest. Speaking of which …

  2. Making interest on all banking accounts really adds up! A major reason many people use online banking is for their high interest rates, on both savings as well as checking accounts. While I had been using the online bank Emigrant Direct for my savings account, I had never seen it worth the hassle to setup an interest bearing checking account at a local bank that would earn me 0.25%. Now that all my accounts earn interest automatically though, I find all those dollars really adding up. Also, being able to transfer money from checking to savings instantly earns me more interest in the end, instead of my previous method of having to wait a week for the funds to move over.
  3. Not having any ATM fees, ever, is just as good as it sounds. A few days after setting up my account, I went to my favorite local sub place – and forgot that they only accepted cash. The cashier pointed to the ATM machine in the corner, and I told him thanks but I’d rather avoid the $3 machine fee and $2 fee from my bank for not using an in-network machine. And then it dawned on me that my new online bank didn’t charge any fees and reimbursed any machine fees! I have to say that this has been my favorite aspect of online banking. Whether it’s visiting my family in Ohio, withdrawing some money at a casino, or just needing some quick cash for a turkey sub, not having to worry about ATM charges is fantastic. The ATM fees still initially go through, but are reimbursed in one to two weeks.
  4. Depositing is a slight inconvenience. I know, depositing by mailing my check should be just as easy, in theory, as depositing at the ATM. But it isn’t. Normally, I would deposit any checks I had at the time I was making a withdrawal, which was easy enough. Now, I have to find an envelope, write out the address, find a stamp, and make a trip to a mailbox (which for some reason is a mile away from where I live). Besides that, I am more hesitant to put checks in the mail. I like depositing into an ATM because I can see the result immediately online. Not to mention mailing cash for a deposit is impossible. So instead I’ve met halfway by depositing in my local account and then transferring to my online account. Still this isn’t ideal as it now takes seven business days to get that money.
  5. Consolidating accounts into one bank makes organizing my finances much easier. Before, when my checking account was at a local bank, my only option to earn decent interest on my savings was to have it in an online bank. Besides the delay in transferring money between the accounts (as mentioned above), it also meant multiple logins to see my account status, multiple statements, etc. Now my account, my wife’s account, our savings and our business accounts are all at the same place. As long as we don’t surpass the $100,000 FDIC limit, I see this being a good thing.

Overall, I am very happy with my decision to move online. The slight inconveniences are far outweighed by the advantages. I didn’t go into too many details on my specific bank, HSBC Direct, but suffice it to say I am very happy with them. They were one of the online banks that offered complete ATM fee reimbursements (something the popular ING Direct does not), no other fees to speak of, competitive interest rates, and a great online interface.

They do not, however, offer referral bonuses, which may be why you don’t see it mentioned as often as ING Direct on other personal finance sites.

I kid, I kid!


Having trouble finding low cost loans? Let The Thrifty Scot help with comparing over 500 loan plans at a glance

18 Comments so far
Leave a comment

In regard to #1, ING Electric Orange gives you the option to have them mail a paper check for you. I’ve had both HSBC and ING accounts and I’ve also found that transfers take less time with ING than HSBC.

Yep, ING is definitely a good option as well as HSBC. Even with their paper checks though I still found myself in a fair number of situations where I needed to hand a check to someone in person.

I do wish my transfers were slightly faster with HSBC though. They officially take 4 business days but that countdown seems to start the day after I initiate it, which is kind of bordering on ridiculousness.

[...] from The Money Mythos presents Five Advantages and Disadvantages to Online Banking. As a product of the computer age, I took the plunge into online banking a few years ago, and there [...]

I have been using ING as my checking a savings for almost a year now, and I have learned to write almost no paper checks.

When I first switched, I wrote a couple of months. Now, pretty much everywhere will take credit/debit if they take checks. The world is adjusting to all electronic, and so am I.

I also haven’t needed counter services like I thought either which makes me pretty close to canceling my Wachovia account.

I don’t agree that going to an ATM is easier, since I never go now…mailing is easier for me.

And interest does add up. I made almost 1000 in interest last year.

Interesting read. I keep one local checking account with minimal cash in it for some of the items you mention. I also have a Capital One MMA that pays decent interest and offers check writing.

Best Wishes,

I started with ING but have since moved to EverBank, which does offer checkwriting, but I hardly ever use it as I kept my local account. There are always times when you really need that “bank down the street,” and it’s easy to move money between them.

Great Article,

Bob McD

[...] Five Advantages and Disadvantages to Online Banking [...]

[...] is the Enemy of Progress My Sources of Alternative Income and How I Make Them Work For Me Five Advantages and Disadvantages to Online Banking Wedding as a Status [...]

One other option instead of a paper check for those times that it doesn’t work out. Money orders using cash from the ATM. Sure they are 1.05 to 1.50 each but it’ll do the job. Or getting cash from the ATM than depositing it in your local bank to cover your check instant availablity. If you need more that the ATM daily withdrawl limit, i.e. the $500 at my bank you just call them and ask that the limit be raised for the day.

Great point. I hadn’t thought about withdrawing cash from my online account and getting a money order. I wouldn’t want to do it all the time but for those emergency situations $1 isn’t bad at all.

Whatever way we choose to look at it, banking on the net is certainly better than the traditional banking. Even the inconveniences mentioned are still less than one would encounter in a traditional banking situation. One thing that stands out is the fact that banking is all about money. And in today’s knowledge driven economies, every minute can be translated into cash, if only one can find out ways. So the minutes one would have otherwise wasted in bank qeues in the traditional banking situation are saved, and converted into money. One serious concern that tends to come up regarding banking on the net is the issue of security. But then again, the incidences of this are few and far apart, and taking protective measures goes a long way in reducing them even further. Generally speaking, weighing between guaranteed convenience and ‘a low probability’ security scare, I think I would opt for the convenience, since this is assured.

Money orders work the other way too. You had mentioned that you couldn’t / shouldn’t deposit cash by mail. You could instead use the cash to purchase a money order payable to yourself, and then mail it in with a deposit slip as you would any other check. Cost is a buck or 2, but probably less than your interbank transfer fee.

What are the disadvantages and more advantages of online banking

closed? already? im heart broken..

Great article on online banking, I especially liked how you laid out all of the benefits. I found this other great article at Investing Ed:
Which covers some more pros and cons of online banking.

I think you should have put 5 of each and specified which is which because they are very unclear as to what one is the advantage and what one is the disadvantage … thanks for your time.
ps i think you had some good points though!

I think you should have put 5 of each and specified which is which because they are very unclear as to what one is the advantage and what one is the disadvantage … thanks for your time.
pls i think you had some good points though


We sell spamming…

Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>